Nate holds an open Bible while Luther chases a skeleton carrying the 95 Theses—a visual collision of Reformation history and the question of assurance.

Happy Reformation Day Eve: Can a Christian Doubt Their Salvation? (Judah Smith & More)

What do you get when you mix Reformation Day Eve, a megachurch pastor who thinks you can be Hindu and follow Jesus, and a caller brave enough to ask the question everyone whispers? You get an episode of the Ask A Christian Podcast that refuses to flinch. Nate opens with the lighter side of October 31st—Martin Luther, the 95 Theses, and why Christians can just dress up as the reformer and dodge the Halloween debate entirely—before pivoting to the headlines. The Everett, Washington school district just cut a $275,000 check after forcing students to hide Bibles in sealed envelopes. Then there’s Judah Smith, the Seattle pastor who told his podcast audience you can call yourself whatever you want as long as you “meet Jesus.” But the heart of the stream lands when Keith asks the question that keeps so many believers awake at night: can a Christian doubt their salvation? Nate’s answer is not a shrug. It is Scripture, applied with pastoral precision.

Doubting Salvation: The Biblical Bottom Line

The question of whether a genuine Christian can doubt their salvation is not a sign of weak faith—it is often a sign of a conscience awakening to the weight of sin and the cost of grace. Nate walks through the distinction between the Holy Spirit’s conviction and the enemy’s accusation. The Bible is clear: “Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved” (Romans 10:13). If you are calling on Christ, you are not outside the promise. But the apostle John also tells us that “if our heart condemns us, God is greater than our heart” (1 John 3:20), and that perfect love casts out fear (1 John 4:18). The answer to doubt is not to dig deeper into your own performance—it is to look harder at the finished work of Christ. For a deeper foundation on the doctrines that anchor assurance, see our Christian catechism for adults. And for help sharing these truths with gentleness when someone you love is wrestling with doubt, our guide on graceful disagreement is a practical next step.

Judah Smith, Hindu Followers of Jesus, and the Missing Word: Repentance

Judah Smith’s comments, originally made on the Miracle Mentality podcast and amplified by Protestia, set off a firestorm for a reason. Smith said, “I’ve got a friend who’s like, ‘I’m still Hindu, but I follow Jesus.’ I’m like, ‘Cool, bro. You think I care?’”. The problem is not the desire to see people meet Jesus. The problem is the assumption that meeting Jesus requires nothing of your old allegiance. As ChurchLeaders reported, critics like John K. Amanchukwu called the take “unbiblical”. The biblical Jesus does not simply add Himself to a pantheon. He commands repentance. He is not a supplement. He is the exclusive Lord who said, “No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6). The question is not whether someone can use the label “Christian.” The question is whether they have turned from idols to serve the living God (1 Thessalonians 1:9).

Equip yourself for conversations about doubt, assurance, and the exclusive claims of Christ—Nate’s book gives you biblical clarity for the questions people are actually asking.

Buy on Amazon