Can God’s sovereignty coexist with your free will? On Ask A Christian Podcast, my discussion with Greg Boyd unpacked open theism explained—a view that sparks fiery debates among reformers and skeptics. Open theism posits God knows every possibility, not a scripted outcome, making your choices matter. We dug into this, blending theology with wit—Boyd’s a speed metal fan, which adds a unique perspective. But here’s the key takeaway: whether you lean Calvinist or open theist, the gap narrows when you dig deep. Prayer isn’t a cosmic suggestion box but genuine communication. Let’s dive in!

Open Theism Explained: The Basics

Open theism explained hinges on God granting genuine free will to foster uncoerced love. Boyd likened forced worship to a “Barbie doll” mouthing programmed praise—hardly love. Free will means possibilities are real: you pick path A or B, and God knows every option exhaustively. Exodus 13:17 (BibleGateway) shows God adjusting His plan, anticipating Israel’s fear. This isn’t a clueless deity; it’s a brilliant one, ready for every choice. Yet, James 1:5 reminds us God’s wisdom is boundless—He knows all things. So, does open theism’s “possible futures” align with that? The view certainly presents a compelling case worthy of consideration.

Dive deeper into defending your faith with Nate’s book on apologetics and thoughtful religious discussion.

Buy on Amazon

Calvinism vs. Open Theism: A Graceful Disagreement

Calvinists often sound like God micromanages every molecule, but many clarify: God sustains existence itself. Without God creating the “sandbox” of reality, evil couldn’t exist—not because He causes it, but because He actualizes the framework where free choices play out. They argue this sustaining act gets conflated with control, yet aligns with human will (Romans 9:16). Open theism sees God knowing trillions of outcomes as if each were the only one—a nuance that feels like a nudge from exhaustive foreknowledge. James 1:5 (BibleGateway) affirms God’s omniscience, suggesting these views aren’t as far apart as they might seem. At Ask A Christian, we see this as a graceful disagreement—both sides, boiled down, are closer than naysayers admit. For more on navigating theological differences with charity, explore our piece on graceful disagreement.

Your Role in God’s Plan

Open theism explained means your choices shape eternity. Boyd stated, “We help create what the future holds.” Your prayers and decisions aren’t scripted—they’re real, echoing 1 Corinthians 3:9, where we’re God’s “co-workers.” Calvinists might say God’s sustaining act enables your will, but both views affirm your significance. Revelation 22:5 promises we’ll reign with Christ, learning authority now. So, next time you’re reflecting on your day, know your choices matter. How does that understanding shift your approach to prayer and decision-making? This topic is part of our ongoing exploration in Theology Unpacked.

A Note on My Theological Position

While exploring open theism is valuable for understanding different Christian perspectives, my own position aligns with the classical view of God’s sovereignty. I believe Scripture reveals a God who knows the future exhaustively and certainly—not merely possibilities, but what will absolutely happen. This isn’t a predetermined script that negates our will, but rather reflects His eternal and perfect knowledge, encompassing all of time in a single present moment (Isaiah 46:9-10). This certainty underscores the magnificent mystery of a God so sovereign that human free will operates within the bounds of His perfect knowledge and ultimate decree.

Open theism explained, like Calvinism, reveals a God who’s either sustaining your choices or knowing every possibility—both uphold your eternal significance. Romans 8:28 assures He works all for good. At Ask A Christian, we say: why fight over nuances when both sides, at their core, exalt God’s wisdom? The real battle’s out there, not here. For more resources and discussions, find all of our links at our Linktree.

What’s one choice you’re making to shape eternity? These conversations are made possible by listener support. If this content has been valuable to you, consider contributing to the mission at this link.

Share this: #OpenTheismExplained #GregBoyd #AskAChristian